Long Island has some of the best Greek food you’ll find outside of Greece. But where is the best Greek food on Long Island located? Let’s not waste any more time because right now We bring you this year’s winners for Best Greek Food on Long Island.
Long Islanders Voted Aegean Cafe in Sayville Best Greek Food on Long Island!
1. Aegean Café
35 Main St., Sayville. 631-589-5529. www.sayvilleaegeancafe.com
The Aegean Café has it all—Greek music, Greek artwork, Greek hospitality, and most importantly, Greek food. Whether it’s the Dolmades, stuffed tender grape leaves stuffed and moistened with olive oil and lemon, or the Gyro Melt—that’s right, Gyro Melt—fresh sliced gyro meat on a pita, with grilled onions, tomatoes, and melted mozzarella cheese, this extensive menu has a lot of everything, including a full-range of pasta specialties, a melt-in-your-mouth Tartufo and the best wild card ever: the cake of the day.
2. Ayhan’s Shish Kebab
Multiple Locations. www.ayhansrestaurants.com
Ayhan’s lively atmosphere can only be matched by it’s amazingly authentic Greek cuisine. Their fusion-style menu combines the best dishes from Greece with some of the best dishes from Turkey, Israel and Cyprus. Ayhan’s has been on Long Island for more than 35 years, and their experience shows.
3. Mediterranean Snack Bar
360 New York Ave., Huntington. 631-423-8982. www.medsnackbar.com
The Mediterranean Snack Bar has been serving up fine Greek eats–seafood, salads, grape leaves, pitas–for more than 29 years they’d expect to find on an island in the Aegean Sea. Owner Steve Soulellis has called Huntington Village his home for more than 40 years. His customers are his neighbors, so you know this place has got to be good.
