The best pet shop on Long Island has everything you need, from pets to pet supplies. Whether youíre looking for a new pet or buying food and supplies for one you already have, these stores have quality service and will help you get exactly what you need. We bring you this yearís winners for Best Pet Shop on Long Island.
Long Islanders voted Selmer’s Pet Land in South Huntington the Best Pet Shop on Long Island!
1. Selmer’s Pet Land
125 E. Jericho Tpke., South Huntington. 631-423-4677. www.selmerspetland.com
In addition to topping the list of Best Pet Groomers, Selmer’s Pet Land in South Huntington is Long Island’s Best Pet Shop—for a whopping sixth consecutive year. Selmer’s is independently owned and operated, and it sells a wide array of pets, including dogs, fish, reptiles, birds and small mammals, along with a variety of services and products for those pets.
2. Love My Puppies
745 Wantagh Ave., Wantagh. 516-804-5399. www.lovemypuppiesny.com
Like the name of the business reads, Love My Puppies in Wantagh specializes in just puppies. This pet shop is unique because all the puppies are handpicked by the owner. Love My Puppies is independently owned and operated, and it sells products for puppies and offers grooming seven days a week by appointment.
3. The Peticular Pet
71 E. Main St., Huntington. 631-427-7328. www.peticularpet.com
If you’re looking for pets out of the ordinary The Peticular Pet is the place for you. It doesn’t sell cats and dogs, but The Peticular Pet sells a wide variety of pets, including guinea pigs, hamsters, lizards, snakes, fish, chinchillas and much more. Customers like the idea of going into a pet shop and being able to find a wide range of animals. The Peticular Pet does offer food and products for animals including, cats and dogs. It also offers in home services, boarding for animals and deliveries of all products to customers homes.
Multiple locations. www.petco.com