Best Bar on Long Island

What makes a good bar great? Let us count the ways. The people are fun, the staff is friendly, the choices of brews and mixed drinks are out of this world. There’s music if you feel like listening, there’s romancing if you’re in the mood for love. Or if you just want to share a few laughs and tell wonderful tales, you can do that there, too. That’s what makes a good bar great. It’s a tough call deciding which bar is the best, but here’s the winner for this year.

2024: Long Island Voted Po’Boy Brewery Best Bar!

Po’Boy Brewery
200 Wilson St., Unit E3, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 828-1131 – poboybrewery.com

Po’Boy Brewery is a craft beer haven that embodies the spirit of creativity and community. This brewery has become a local gem, celebrated for its diverse selection of handcrafted beers that showcase innovation and quality. From hop-forward IPAs to rich stouts and flavorful ales, Po’Boy Brewery’s offerings cater to a spectrum of beer enthusiasts. The inviting and laid-back atmosphere of the brewery creates a welcoming space for patrons to savor unique brews while fostering a sense of camaraderie. With a commitment to both traditional brewing methods and experimental flavors, Po’Boy Brewery stands as a beloved destination for those seeking a dynamic and flavorful experience in the world of craft beer on Long Island.

2023: Long Islanders Voted Po’Boy Brewery Best Bar!

Po’Boy Brewery
200 Wilson St., Unit E3, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 828-1131 – poboybrewery.com

When it comes to beers, ciders, and cocktails, Po’ Boy Brewery is setting the bar. Founded by national award-winning expert brewer Bob Rodriguez, Po’ Boy offers only the best brews around. Its wide variety of options include Lagers, Pilsners, IPAs, ciders, and everything in between. Better yet, the selection of craft beers are made locally on Long Island. Plus, what night out would be complete without some crave-worthy bar food? Po’ Boy offers pizza, nachos, and the perfect soft pretzel. The high-quality ales, food, and atmosphere make it the ideal game day location or the perfect spot to catch up with some friends. Whether you’re looking for a traditional beer or a new brew, Po’ Boy has the drink for you.

2022: Long Islanders Voted Po’Boy Brewery Best Bar!

Po’Boy Brewery
200 Wilson St., Unit E3, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 828-1131 – poboybrewery.com

Po’Boy Brewery boasts a beautiful, cozy taproom and welcoming staff. Most have called it a pleasant and fun place to unwind and get together with friends and family. It is also one of the few places in the country classified as both a brewery and a cidery! Po’Boy Brewery rotates its taps regularly so that you can experience a new flavor and style weekly. The Tasting Room and Sour Patch have more than 20 varieties of beer and cider to sample flights and to order pints from. Growlers can be filled and four-packs can be purchased for off-premise consumption as well. There are several food options to choose from, plus special events and celebrations, live music on specified nights, and a variety of options for hosting your special event.

2021: Long Islanders Voted Po’Boy Brewery Best Bar!

Po’Boy Brewery
200 Wilson St Unit E3, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 828-1131 – poboybrewery.com

Po’Boy Brewery, located in Port Jefferson Station, boasts a beautiful and cozy taproom and welcoming staff. Most have called us a pleasant and fun place to unwind and get together with friends and family. We are one of the few places in the country that is identified as a Brewery and a Cidery! We rotate our taps regularly so that you can experience a new flavor and style weekly! The Tasting Room and Sour Patch have over 20 varieties of beer and cider to sample flights and to order pints from. Growlers can be filled and four-packs can be purchased for off-premise consumption as well. Several food options to choose from, special events and celebrations, live music on specified nights, and we also offer options of all varieties for hosting your special event. It has been a pure joy to grow, expand and define our unique, innovative approach to craft beer and we have had a damn good time doing it! Thank you for your support and for voting us the BEST on Long Island! We will see you on the other side of the bar!

2020: Long Islanders Voted One Eye Jacks Best Bar On Long Island!

One Eye Jacks
380 N Wantagh Ave, Bethpage
(516) 342-1732 – facebook.com/oneeyejacksli

For a truly unique and exciting experience, head over to One Eye Jacks in Bethpage. The 21 and older clientele fills One Eye Jacks on Friday and Saturday nights to listen to top bands and DJ’s perform, in a total party atmosphere. Monthly dance parties and specialty shows have been a huge draw. Open Mic nights bring enormous energy, as musicians showcase their talents. Signature drinks and 100 oz Beer Towers are the highlights of OEJ’s liquor and beer menu. One Eye Jacks also compliments its drinks with an extensive food menu. If you are looking for sports, you can always find a sporting event on one of OEJ’s ten flat screens.

2019: Long Islanders Voted One Eye Jacks Best Bar On Long Island!

One Eye Jacks
380 N. Wantagh Ave., Bethpage
(516) 342-1732 – facebook.com/oneeyejacksli

For a truly unique and exciting bar experience, head over to One Eye Jacks in Bethpage. In addition to standard pours of their brews, the bartenders at One Eye Jacks fill up signature fish bowls, 100-oz. beer towers, and other specialties. The 21-and-older bar is a community space where people gather to listen to DJs spin music and watch flat screen TVs showing sports. One Eye Jacks complements its drinks with bar food, and they serve a buffet during special events.

2018: Long Islanders Voted One Eye Jacks Best Bar on Long Island

One Eye Jacks

380 N. Wantagh Ave., Bethpage. 516-342-1732.

Once you visit One Eye Jacks in Bethpage, it’s sure to become your favorite watering hole. This bar has everything; from atmosphere, drinks specials, signature fish bowls, 100-oz. beer towers and other specialties, plasma screen TV’s and great music are all part of the party package. Featuring wild events for every occasion and drink specials every night, you will be able to have the happiest hour without breaking the bank. If you need a place to watch the game or just want to unwind after work at the ultimate happy hour, One Eye Jacks is for you! It’s five o’clock somewhere, right?

2017: Long Islanders Voted BrickHouse Brewery & Restaurant Best Bar on Long Island

BrickHouse Brewery & Restaurant
67 W. Main St., Patchogue. 631-447-2337. brickhousebrewery.com
Housed in a building that dates back to 1850, BrickHouse Brewery & Restaurant, there’s a lot of history surrounding this consistent ‘Best Of’ honoree. Its home’s foundation was built from a ship ballast, and during the Civil War, the place was a stop on the Underground Railroad! Old-time locals say it’s predecessor, Shand’s, had just about everything, which is fitting, since voters undoubtedly recognize the same thing about BrickHouse. Whether it’s BrickHouse’s phenomenal food, exceptional home brews, friendly staff, beautiful local artwork, amazing vibes, or extraordinary live musical performances and events, Long Islanders agree: BrickHouse Brewery & Restaurant is the Best Bar on Long Island!

2016: Long Islanders Voted Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge Best Bar on Long Island

Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge
4 Patchogue Dr., Rocky Point. 631-744-4100. spiroslounge.com
Raise a glass to Spiro Karachopan, born in Greece in 1954, who has made his mark on Long Island nightlife in 2016 by earning top honors as the founder/owner of The Best bar on Long Island for Spiro’s Lounge & Restaurant, which rightfully bears his name. Are you thirsty, friends? Here’s looking at you. The cocktails are shaken, stirred, on the rocks or served straight up, whatever your pleasure. These mixologists are the masters of their craft. The cocktails are amazing. The scene is hopping, and the atmosphere is full of fun and good cheer. From the drinks to the food, Spiro’s is the place to be, as evident by Spiro’s many appearances atop this prestigious list!

2015: Long Islanders Voted BrickHouse Brewery & Restaurant Best Bar on Long Island!

BrickHouse Brewery & Restaurant
67 W. Main St., Patchogue. 631-447-2337. brickhousebrewery.com

The building may go back to 1850 when it first took shape but there’s nothing dated about the lively spirit overflowing inside this homegrown brewery and restaurant in the heart of Patchogue, where fine food and great brews are always on tap. From its inception, the BrickHouse has been proud to pour its own flagship beers, but they’ll offer customers other favorite brands, too, because they live to serve, and that’s the mark of any great bar. Yet when it comes to crafting creations, they strive to keep it hopping. They’ve collaborated with Patchogue’s Roast Coffee & Tea Trading Company for the third straight year to create a new, festive beer for the holiday season, complete with a mocha finish called Main Street Mocha Porter. This place is a-hoppin’ and a-boppin’!

2014: Long Islanders Voted  BrickHouse Brewery & Restaurant in Patchogue Best Bar on Long Island!

1. BrickHouse Brewery & Restaurant
67 W. Main St., Patchogue. 631-447-2337. brickhousebrewery.com

2. Post Office Café
130 W. Main St., Babylon. 631-669-9224. lessings.com

3. Croxley’s Ale House & Eatery
Multiple Locations. croxley.com

2013: Long Islanders Voted Croxley’s Ale House & Eatery Best Bar on Long Island!

1. Croxley’s Ale House & Eatery
Multiple Locations. www.croxley.com

2. Post Office Café
130 W. Main St., Babylon. 631-669-9224. www.lessings.com

3. Even Flow Bar and Grill
150 E. Main St., Bay Shore. 631-665-9696. www.evenflowbarandgrill.com

2012: Long Islanders Voted The Leaky Lifeboat Inn in Seaford Best Bar on Long Island!

1. The Leaky Lifeboat Inn
3603 Merrick Rd., Seaford.

2. The Nutty Irishman
Multiple Locations. www.thenuttyirishman.com

3. Croxley Ale House
Multiple Locations. www.croxley.com

2011: Long Islanders Voted Croxley’s Ale House Best Bar on Long Island!

1. Croxley’s Ale House
Multiple locations. www.croxley.com

2. Post Office Café
130 West Main St., Babylon. 631-669-9224. www.lessings.com

3. Mulcahy’s Pub & Concert Hall
Multiple locations. www.muls.com

2010: Long Islanders Voted Croxley Ales The Best Bar On Long Island!

1. Croxley Ales
Multiple locations www.croxley.com

2. Mulcahy’s Pub & Concert Hall
3232 Railroad Ave., Wantagh. 516-783-7500. 1702 Middle Country Rd., Centereach. 631-696-1111. www.muls.com

3. Post Office Cafe
130 W. Main St., Babylon. 631-669-9224. www.lessings.com