Best Hero on Long Island
Some big food chains have introduced lobster rolls to their menus, but there’s nothing quite like one from a local Long Island restaurant. Lobster meat soaked in butter and served on a steamed hotdog bun makes the perfect lunch or dinner on the way home from the beach over the summer. And with so many delicious lobster rolls on the island to choose from, we can imagine this was a tough one for Long Islanders to vote on. But regardless, make sure you try the Best Lobster Roll on Long Island.
2024: Long Island Voted DJ’s Clam Shack Best Lobster Roll!
DJ’s Clam Shack
1007 RT 25A, Stony Brook
(631) 675-9669 – djsclamshack.com/stony-brook
DJ’s Clam Shack proudly boasts the title of purveyor of the finest lobster rolls in the region. Renowned for their dedication to culinary excellence, they offer two tantalizing options: the classic Maine Lobster Roll and the indulgent Overstuffed Maine Lobster Roll, both accompanied by delectable coleslaw. What sets DJ’s apart is their commitment to quality; each roll bursts with succulent, freshly-caught lobster meat, perfectly seasoned and expertly prepared. With every bite, patrons are transported to the shores of Maine, savoring the essence of coastal dining. For lobster aficionados, DJ’s Clam Shack is an unrivaled destination.
2023: Long Islanders Voted The Lobster Roll aka LUNCH Best Lobster Roll!
The Lobster Roll aka LUNCH
1980 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett
(631) 267-3740 – lobsterroll.com
Nothing hits the spot quite like a lobster roll, especially in the summer. If you’re looking for the best, you want to go to a place aptly named The Lobster Roll. Also known as “Lunch,” the Lobster Roll has been serving up the freshest seafood for guests, including the classic lobster roll and the hot lobster roll, both of which are popular items among diners. It makes for the perfect option for an afternoon out with your lobster-loving friends. Want to make your own lobster roll at home? The Lobster Roll sells a lobster roll kit complete with one pound of lobster meat, mayo, packets of Lobster Roll’s seasoning, rolls, a lemon, and a few bags of North Fork Chips. One word: Yum!
2022: Long Islanders Voted The Lobster Roll aka LUNCH Best Lobster Roll!
The Lobster Roll aka LUNCH
1980 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett
(631) 267-3740 – lobsterroll.com
Nothing hits the spot quite like a lobster roll, especially in the summer. If you’re looking for the best, you want to go to a place aptly named The Lobster Roll. Also known as “Lunch,” the Lobster Roll has been serving up the freshest seafood for guests, including the classic lobster roll and the hot lobster roll, both of which are popular items among diners. It makes for the perfect option for an afternoon out with your lobster-loving friends. Want to make your own lobster roll at home? The Lobster Roll sells a lobster roll kit complete with one pound of lobster meat, mayo, packets of Lobster Roll’s seasoning, rolls, a lemon, and a few bags of North Fork Chips. One word: Yum!
2021: Long Islanders Voted The Lobster Roll aka LUNCH Best Lobster Roll!
The Lobster Roll aka LUNCH
1980 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett
(631) 267-3740 – lobsterroll.com
Since 1965, Lobster Roll, affectionately called LUNCH, has been serving the people of Long Island the best lobster they can find. Known far and wide for its lobster rolls, the simply-named eatery has been a seafood hot-spot since day one. Locals know it’s the only place to get a great bite of fresh, chewey lobster on a soft, buttery roll. What could possibly be more amazing than that on a hot, summer day? This retro shack brings people back and welcomes everyone with a smile, continuing to serve extraordinary dishes that are unmatched in presentation and taste. Take one bite and you’ll never want to order a lobster roll anywhere else!
2020: Long Islanders Voted The Lobster Roll Best Lobster Roll!
The Lobster Roll
1980 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett
(631) 267-3740 – lobsterroll.com
Since 1965, Lobster Roll, affectionately called LUNCH, has been serving the people of Long Island the best lobster they can find. Known for their lobster rolls, the Lobster Roll has been a seafood hot-spot since day one. Locals know it’s the only place to get a great bite of fresh seafood. What could possibly be more amazing than that on a hot, summer day? This retro shack brings people back and welcomes everyone with a smile. They continue to serve extraordinary dishes that are unmatched in presentation and taste. Lobster Roll continues to serve up the best lobster rolls on Long Island, and Long Islanders continue to eat them up!
2019: Long Islanders Voted The Lobster Roll Best Lobster Roll!
The Lobster Roll
1980 Montauk Hwy., Amagansett
(631) 267-3740 – www.lobsterroll.com
Long Island lobster is a huge part of the local cuisine and The Lobster Roll fits the bill perfectly. The Lobster Roll was purchased in 1965 by Frederick H. Terry Sr., and his dad; Richard C. Terry Sr. when it was a tiny roadside clam shack on the Napeague stretch. The Lobster Roll Restaurant became affectionately known as “ Lunch “ (although it serves lunch and dinner) because locals and travelers associated the now “iconic“ sign with the restaurant. The Lobster Roll has transformed over the years, through several expansions, but remains the quintessential indoor/ outdoor summer eatery; attracting locals, celebrities, day-trippers, and travelers from all over the globe!!! The Lobster Roll embraces the atmosphere of a nostalgic roadside shack, amid the sand dunes, gardens of summer flowers, umbrellas, beach balls, picnic tables, and plenty of smiling faces!
2018: Long Islanders Voted Jordan’s Lobster Farm Best Lobster Roll on Long Island
Jordan’s Lobster Farm 1 Pettit Pl., Island Park 516-889-3314 jordanlobsterfarms.com
Family owned and operated for more than half a century, Jordan Lobster Farm carries on a tradition began so long ago by Bill Jordan and continued to this day by his sons. Jordan’s Maine Lobster Roll is a work of sheer beauty—thick, succulent crustacean with all the fixings snuggled comfortably between the halves of a soft, warm roll, accompanied by French fries and a pickle. Wow.
2017: Long Islanders Voted The Lobster Roll – Northside Best Lobster Roll on Long Island
The Lobster Roll – Northside
3225 Sound Ave., Riverhead. 631-369-3039. lobsterrollnorthside.com
There’s nothing like a tasty lobster roll in the middle of the summer to make your taste buds leap with joy! The Lobster Roll Restaurant – Northside in Riverhead not only offers customers fresh, yummy lobster (as pointed out right in the name!), but also a great atmosphere with comfortable indoor and outdoor seating and a friendly staff. You can order a classic lobster roll, a lobster salad slider or platter, or a hot lobster roll sautéed in garlic butter and served with tasty French fries. The choice is up to you! Yummy!
2016: Long Islanders Voted Jordan’s Lobster Farm Best Lobster Roll on Long Island
Jordan’s Lobster Farm
1 Pettit Pl., Island Park. 516-889-3314. jordanlobsterfarms.com
Family owned and operated for more than half a century, Jordan Lobster Farm carries on a tradition began so long ago by Bill Jordan and continued to this day by his sons. Jordan’s Maine Lobster Roll is a work of sheer beauty—thick, succulent crustacean with all the fixings snuggled comfortably between the halves of a soft, warm roll, accompanied by French fries and a pickle. Wow.
2015: Long Islanders Voted The Lobster Roll – Northside Best Lobster Roll on Long Island!
The Lobster Roll – Northside
3225 Sound Ave., Riverhead. 631-369-3039. lobsterroll.com
It’s tough to beat a high-quality lobster roll, the crustacean is served hot, sauteed in garlic butter, enveloped in fresh coleslaw and served alongside an equally fresh batch of French fries. Maybe you prefer this oceanic beauty cold, eagerly awaiting your lips atop a toasted bun. The Lobster Roll—with a sister spot in Amagansett—literally created the popular dish, and as they say, there’s quite simply nothing like the original. Long Islanders vote this one The Best, and if you’ve never experienced this glorious beast, do yourself a favor and head East to devour this LI gem!
2014: Long Islanders Voted Flo’s Luncheonette in Blue Point Best Lobster Roll on Long Island!
1. Flo’s Luncheonette
302 Middle Rd., Blue Point. 888-FLOS-TOGO. flosfamous.com
2. Jordan’s Lobster Farm
1 Pettit Pl., Island Park. 516-889-3314. jordanlobsterfarms.com
3. Lobster Roll
3225 Sound Ave., Riverhead. 631-369-3039. lobsterroll.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Lobster Roll Best Lobster Roll on Long Island!
1. Lobster Roll
Multiple Locations. www.lobsterroll.com
2. Jordan Lobster Farms
1 Pettit Place, Island Park. 516-889-3314. www.jordanlobsterfarms.com
3. Flo’s Luncheonette
302 Middle Rd., Blue Point. 888-FLOS-TOGO. www.flosfamous.com
2012: Long Islanders Voted The Lobster Roll Best Lobster Roll on Long Island!
1. The Lobster Roll
Multiple Locations. www.lobsterroll.com
2. Jordan’s Lobster Farm
1 Pettit Pl., Island Park. 516-889-3314. www.jordanlobsterfarms.com
3. The Fishery
1 Main St., East Rockaway. 516-256-7117.
NATIONAL
Legal Seafood
Multiple Locations. www.legalseafoods.com
2011: Long Islanders Voted Lobster Roll in Riverhead Best Lobster Roll on Long Island
1. Lobster Roll
Main St., Amagansett. 631-267-3740; 3225 Sound Ave., Riverhead. 631-369-3039. www.lobsterroll.com
2. Jordan’s Lobster Farms
1 Pettit Pl., Island Park. 516-889-3314. www.jordanlobsterfarms.com
3. Blackstone Steakhouse
10 Pinelawn Rd., Melville. 631-271-7780. www.blackstonesteakhouse.com
Related posts