The many choices of American/Continental cuisine on Long Island made this a tough choice for voters. With so many terrific spots to pick from, it’s not easy to name the best. But these contenders came out on top.
Long Islanders Have Voted Argyle Grill & Tavern In Babylon The Best American/Continental Restaurant on Long Island!
Argyle Grill & Tavern
90 Deer Park Ave.
Babylon
631-321-4900
www.theargylegrill.com
Every village on LI should be so lucky as to have this inviting, cosmopolitan local favorite to come to, for innovative, thoughtfully prepared dinners or just a top-notch burger lunch. It was an immediate hit when it opened and has become a mainstay of Babylon’s burgeoning dining scene.
2nd Place - Tellers Restaurant. 605 Main St., Islip. 631-277-7070. www.tellerschophouse.com
Serving both lunch and dinner, guests can look forward to beautiful architecture and sculptures within. They serve great steaks, chops and seafood dishes along with a cocktail area.
3rd Place – Milk & Sugar Cafe. 49 W. Main St., Bay Shore. 631-969-4430. www.milkandsugarcafe.com
This café has a very intimate, elegant, and sophisticated setting and is located in Bay Shore. They serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
Directions to Argyle Grill & Tavern:
