2010 Winners | 2011 Winners

These are the 2012 Best of L.I. results.

Click here to view the 2013 Bethpage Best of L.I. results.

Best Lobster Roll on Long Island

by Best Of Long Island on January 9, 2012

If you can’t get a stellar lobster roll on Long Island, well, where can you get one? Long Island might as well be called the home of the lobster roll! Now that we’ve established Long Island has some amazing lobster rolls, where do you go to get the Best Lobster Roll? Fret no longer, the votes are in and we bring you this year’s winners for Best Lobster Roll on Long Island.

Long Islanders Voted The Lobster Roll Best Lobster Roll on Long Island!

1. The Lobster Roll

Multiple Locations. www.lobsterroll.com

No seafood restaurant in the world can lay claim to the fact that they actually invented the cold version lobster roll other than Long Island’s very own The Lobster Roll, with two locations, “The Original” in Amagansett and Riverhead’s “Northside.” They’re weighty, loaded with lobster meat stuffed with your favorite salad and sandwiched between a toasted hot dog roll with a side of creamy homemade coleslaw. You’ve really got to try this thing to believe how absolutely delicious it is. After all, The Lobster Roll invented it!

2. Jordan’s Lobster Farm

1 Pettit Pl., Island Park. 516-889-3314. www.jordanlobsterfarms.com

3. The Fishery

1 Main St., East Rockaway. 516-256-7117.

NATIONAL Legal Seafood

Multiple Locations. www.legalseafoods.com

Leave a Comment