Everyone — and we mean everyone — knows that Long Island has the best bagels. Big, soft, round and doughy, they’re delectable in any form. And almost every town, city and hamlet on the island has its own local bagel shop that delivers the best breakfasts and lunches around. So whether you prefer yours with cream cheese or butter, lox or simply plain, try a ball of carbohydrate-goodness from the place you voted the Best Bagels on Long Island this year (and, considering the competition, that’s an honorable title to hold!).
2024: Long Island Voted Blazin Bagel and Deli Best Bagels!
Blazin Bagel and Deli
287 Wading River Rd, Manorville
(631) 230-3255
Blazin Bagel and Deli crafts an extraordinary bagel experience, setting a new standard for excellence in this Long Island breakfast staple. These handcrafted bagels are a testament to quality and authenticity. Boiled and baked to perfection, Blazin Bagel’s creations boast a delightful balance of chewiness and crispness, creating the ideal bagel texture. The menu showcases a variety of flavors, from classic plain and everything bagels to unique options like blueberry and Asiago. Complemented by a selection of artisanal spreads and toppings, each bagel is a culinary delight. Blazin Bagel’s commitment to freshness and flavor ensures that every bite is a savory journey, making it a beloved destination for bagel enthusiasts seeking an exceptional breakfast or brunch experience.
2023: Long Islanders Voted Hilltop Bagel Cafe Best Bagels!
Hilltop Bagel Cafe
623 Horseblock Rd, Farmingville
(631) 846-1828 – hilltopbagelcafe.com
Bagels are a staple of the New York experience, and Hilltop Bagel Café is one business that celebrates them in all their doughy glory. Hilltop Bagel Café is a Farmingville-based eatery that is known for producing delicious bagels in a range of flavors and styles. Providing an impressive breakfast menu, weekly specials, and catering services, Hilltop Bagel Cafe is a beloved staple of the community. Wraps, sandwiches, salads, and desserts are also available for purchase, and the eatery is especially well regarded for its cream cheeses and Italian ices. To learn more or see a full range of Hilltop Bagel Cafe’s delicious offerings and services, visit its website.
2022: Long Islanders Voted A&S Bagels Best Bagels!
A&S Bagels
761 Hempstead Tpke, Franklin Square
516-326-9288 – aandsbagels.com
Many Long Islanders have a favorite bagel shop and they will waste no time defending their choice against anybody who dares to claim another bagel shop is best. But, asked to select their favorite bagels on Long Island, voters selected A&S Bagels more than any other. That could be because of their vast selection of delicious bagel choices, kettle boiled before being baked, and including everything from the traditional plain, sesame, garlic, and salt varieties to more offbeat selections, including blueberry and cheddar cheese. A&S Bagels was likely also selected thanks to its wide selection of cream cheeses and sandwiches, including multiple egg options and “The Greg Special” with bacon, chicken cutlet, Russian dressing, lettuce, and tomato. Long Islanders no doubt also like the fact that they can stop by whenever hunger strikes because A&S is open 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
Bagel Boss (National Winner)
Multiple Locations
(516) 243-8928 – bagelboss.com
“While the infamous Bagel Boss guy catapulted it into nation-wide fame, this shop has built a stellar reputation as the top bagel place on Long Island over the last 50 years. In a region where no one compromises on their bagels, Bagel Boss truly lives up to its name, pleasing even the most discerning palates. Whether you’re craving sesame, egg, poppy and plain — or just everything to make it easy — your eyes will surely wander from basket to basket upon walking into one of its stores. Its team is also happy to bring its doughy delights to your next corporate meeting, luncheon or any other occasion with their local delivery and catering services. Have it with cream cheese, have it with lox — at Bagel Boss, it starts with a bagel and ends with brilliance!”
2021: Long Islanders Voted Bagel Boss Best Bagels!
Bagel Boss
Multiple Locations
(516) 243-8928 – bagelboss.com
“While the infamous Bagel Boss guy catapulted it into nation-wide fame, this shop has built a stellar reputation as the top bagel place on Long Island over the last 50 years. In a region where no one compromises on their bagels, Bagel Boss truly lives up to its name, pleasing even the most discerning palates. Whether you’re craving sesame, egg, poppy and plain — or just everything to make it easy — your eyes will surely wander from basket to basket upon walking into one of its stores. Its team is also happy to bring its doughy delights to your next corporate meeting, luncheon or any other occasion with their local delivery and catering services. Have it with cream cheese, have it with lox — at Bagel Boss, it starts with a bagel and ends with brilliance!”
2020: Long Islanders Voted Bagel Boss Best Bagels on Long Island!
Bagel Boss
Multiple Locations
(718) 736-BOSS – bagelboss.com
While the infamous Bagel Boss guy catapulted them into nation-wide fame, this shop has built a stellar reputation as the top bagel place on Long Island over the last 50 years. In a region where no one compromises on their bagels, Bagel Boss truly lives up to its name, pleasing even the most discerning palates. Whether you’re craving sesame, egg, poppy and plain — or just everything to make it easy — your eyes will surely wander from basket to basket upon walking into one of their stores. They are also happy to bring their doughy delights to your next corporate meeting, luncheon or any other occasion with their local delivery and catering services. Have it with cream cheese, have it with lox — at Bagel Boss, it starts with a bagel and ends with brilliance!
2019: Long Islanders Voted Bagel Boss Best Bagels on Long Island!
Bagel Boss
Multiple Locations
www.bagelboss.com
And the winner is—well, you already know. A longtime champion of the Best Bagel on Long Island category, this bagel store continues to show Long Islanders who’s boss—the bagel boss, that is! With multiple locations throughout the island, including Roslyn, Oceanside and East Northport, Bagel Boss offers the freshest, doughiest bagels that pair exceptionally well with eggs, butter, and/or cream cheese. In the mood for cinnamon raisin? Craving an egg everything? Searching for the perfect sesame? Bagel Boss has it all!
2018: Long Islanders Voted Bagel Boss Best Bagels on Long Island
Bagel BOSS
Multiple Locations. 888-BOSS-TIME. bagelboss.com
And the winner is—well, you already know. A longtime champion of the Best Bagel on Long Island category, this bagel store continues to show Long Islanders who’s boss—the bagel boss, that is! With multiple locations throughout the island, including Roslyn, Oceanside and East Northport, Bagel Boss offers the freshest, doughiest bagels that pair exceptionally well with eggs, butter, and/or cream cheese. In the mood for cinnamon raisin? Craving an egg everything? Searching for the perfect sesame? Bagel Boss has it all!
2017: Long Islanders Voted Bagel Boss Best Bagels on Long Island
Bagel Boss Multiple Locations. 888-BOSS-TIME. bagelboss.com And the winner is—well, you already know. A longtime champion of the Best Bagel on Long Island category, this bagel store continues to show Long Islanders who’s boss—the bagel boss, that is! With multiple locations throughout the island, including Roslyn, Oceanside and East Northport, Bagel Boss offers the freshest, doughiest bagels that pair exceptionally well with eggs, butter, and/or cream cheese. In the mood for cinnamon raisin? Craving an egg everything? Searching for the perfect sesame? Bagel Boss has it all!
2016: Long Islanders Voted Bagel Boss Best Bagels on Long Island
Bagel Boss Multiple Locations. 888-BOSS-TIME. bagelboss.com Doughy, soft, and baked fresh every single day, Bagel Boss offers a wide selection of these filling goodies: plain, egg, cinnamon raisin, garlic, everything, low-carb multi-grain, and many more! B-Squared is staffed by sixth generation bagel makers, offers homemade baked goods, fresh-ground coffee, flagels galore, and several mouth-watering fish-bagel-pastry baskets, platters and packages absolutely guaranteed to satisfy any appetite, and make any occasion memorable.
2015: Long Islanders Voted Bagel Boss Best Bagels on Long Island!
Bagel Boss Multiple Locations. 888-BOSS-TIME. bagelboss.com There’s a good reason there tends to be a fast-moving line inside each Bagel Boss location on any given morning. It’s because anyone who knows anything about bagels on Long Island—and trust us, LI knows bagels well—agrees that Bagel Boss has the freshest, and according to voters, best bagels around!
2014: Long Islanders Voted Bagel Boss Best Bagels on Long Island!
1. Bagel Boss Multiple Locations. 888-BOSS-TIME. bagelboss.com 2. A&S Bagels 761 Hempstead Tpke., Franklin Square. 516-326-9288. aandsbagels.com 3. Town Bagel Multiple Locations. townbagel.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Bagel Boss Best Bagels on Long Island!
1. Bagel Boss Multiple Locations. www.bagelboss.com 2. Lynbrook Bagels 26 Atlantic Ave., Lynbrook. 516-596-0917. www.lynbrookbagels.com 3. A&S Bagels 761 Hempstead Tpke., Franklin Square. 516-326-9288. www.aandsbagels.com
2012: Long Islanders Voted Bagel Boss Best Bagels on Long Island!
1. Bagel Boss Multiple Locations. www.bagelboss.com 2. A&S Bagels 761 Hempstead Tpke., Franklin Square. 516-326-9288. www.aandsbagels.com 3. Blvd Bagels 145 Smithtown Blvd., Nesconset. 631-979-2583. www.blvdbagels.com
2011: Long Islanders Voted Bagel Boss- Multiple Locations- Best Bagels on Long Island!
1. Bagel Boss Multiple locations. www.bagelboss.com 2. Blvd Bagels 145 Smithtown Blvd., Nesconset. 631-979-2583 3. A&S Bagels 761 Hempstead Tpke., Franklin Square. 516-326-9288. www.aandsbagels.com
2010: Long Islanders Have Voted Bagel Boss The Best Bagel On Long Island!
1. Bagel Boss Multiple locations. www.bagelboss.com 2. A&S Bagels 761 Hempstead Tpke., Franklin Square. 516-326-9288. www.aandsbagels.com 3. Town Bagel Multiple locations. www.townbagel.com