Best Catholic School on Long Island

Catholic schools provide high quality education, rooted in strong Catholic beliefs that help keep up students’ faith. With the help of Fathers, Sisters and Brothers, children who attend Catholic school are well-guided and disciplined while at the same time exposed to many of the same experiences they otherwise would have gone through at a public school. If you’re considering enrolling your child in such a school this year, then consider the Best Catholic School on Long Island.

2024: Long Island Voted St. Edward the Confessor School Best Catholic School!

St. Edward the Confessor School
2 Teibrook Ave, Syosset
(516) 921-7767 – stedwardconfessor.org

St. Edward the Confessor School cemented its dominance, clinching the “Best Catholic School” title on Long Island for the 5th time, 4th year in a row. This speaks volumes about their commitment to excellence, faith-based learning, and nurturing young minds. Innovation and a vibrant Eucharistic environment define St. Edward. Daily Mass fosters community and spiritual growth, while cutting-edge teaching ensures academic rigor. In the past decade, graduates secured an average of over $160,000 in scholarships, a testament to their preparation for future success. Beyond their walls, St. Edward extends its reach, collaborating with the Syosset School District for Universal PK. Three faculty members serve as Diocesan Grade Level Leaders, and both the Math & Reading Consultants are at St. Edward, fostering a collaborative spirit and top-notch resources. Adding to the celebration, Principal Mr. Albrecht was named “Best School Principal.” Known for his leadership and data-driven approach, he has spearheaded the school’s transformation since 2012. He credits the school’s success to the faculty and staff, with whom he built a strong Eucharistic-centered community. Under his guidance, St. Edward became a Diocesan leader in technology, data-driven instruction, and fostering a deeply spiritual and connected student body. While Mr. Albrecht’s recent appointment as principal of St. John the Baptist Diocesean High School brings bittersweet news, his legacy of innovation, compassion, and unwavering commitment to Catholic education will continue to inspire and guide the school forward. St. Edward’s achievements, along with Mr. Albrecht’s recognition, exemplify the power of dedication, faith, and collaboration. They’ve not only raised the bar for Catholic education on Long Island, but also woven a tapestry of academic excellence, spiritual growth, and strong community that ensures their continued success for years to come.

2023: Long Islanders Voted St. Edward the Confessor School Best Catholic School!

St. Edward the Confessor School
2 Teibrook Ave, Syosset
(516) 921-7767 – stedwardconfessor.org

The fine faculty at St. Edward the Confessor School makes sure their students learn and grow to become curious, respectful, and well mannered. Every student has the opportunity for specialized attention at this well-regarded Catholic school. The teachers create an environment where children are eager to grasp concepts and take the next step to build their important foundation in all subjects. They learn the value of treating others with kindness, a sense of community, and making lasting friendships. Some graduates refer to St. Edward as “the friendship-making factory” because the friends they make there become lifelong. If you value having your children receive an education in their faith and passion to excel in their academics, St. Edward is the school for your family.

2022: Long Islanders Voted St. Edward the Confessor School Best Catholic School!

St. Edward the Confessor School
2 Teibrook Ave, Syosset
(516) 921-7767 – stedwardconfessor.org

St. Edward the Confessor School has been a safe space for students and a hub for education for more than 60 years. St. Edward’s looks to combine traditional curriculum and methods with modern educational advances in order to provide students with a sound and quality education. The school’s vision is to guide the mind, body, and spirit of the next generation to meet their full potential. The administrators don’t want education to stop once the students graduate as they strive to aspire them to be lifelong learners who never finish questioning the world around them. St. Edward’s also offers a number of unique extracurriculars including drama, dance, and Lego club for students who choose to embrace their creative and pragmatic sides.

2021: Long Islanders Voted St. Edward the Confessor School Best Catholic School!

St. Edward the Confessor School
2 Teibrook Ave, Syosset
(516) 921-7767 – stedwardconfessor.org

St. Edward the Confessor School has been a safe space for students as well as a hub for education for nearly 60 years. St. Edward’s looks to combine traditional curriculum and methods with modern educational advances in order to provide their students with a sound and quality education. The school’s vision is to guide the mind, body and spirit of the next generation to meet their full potential. The administrators don’t want education to stop once the students graduate as they strive to aspire them to be lifelong learners who never finish questioning the world around them. St. Edward’s also offers a number of unique extracurriculars including drama, dance and lego club for students who choose to embrace their creative and pragmatic sides.

2020: Long Islanders Voted Our Lady of Victory Best Catholic School on Long Island!

Our Lady of Victory 
2 Bellmore St, Floral Park
(516) 352-4466 – olvfp.org

Our Lady of Victory School in Floral Park believes that education should not only include academics but also spiritual growth. From early childhood education to the eighth grade, their experienced teachers and faculty are dedicated to the pursuit of academic excellence as they partner with parents to prepare their children to be faith filled as well as independent thinkers who are ready to meet the challenges of the 21st century. The Our Lady of Victory School community lives its mission in a safe, nurturing, friendly, Christian environment.

2019: Long Islanders Voted Our Lady of Mercy Best Catholic School on Long Island!

Our Lady of Mercy
520 S. Oyster Bay Road, Hicksville
(516) 433 7040 – www.olmshicks.org

Long Islanders agree that Our Lady of Mercy provides the best Catholic-based education for young minds. Our Lady of Mercy school provides a comprehensive education that develops and cultivates each student’s academic pursuits, personal gifts and talents in a safe and welcoming environment. They prepare their students to be life-long learners and empower them to use their God-given gifts to make a difference in our world. Our Lady of Mercy inspires the hearts, minds, and spirits of young adults to lead, serve and succeed in their colleges, careers, communities and lives.

2018: Long Islanders Voted St. Edward the Confessor School Best Best Catholic School on Long Island!

St. Edward the Confessor School
2 Teibrook Ave., Syosset, N.Y.
www.stedwardconfessor.org

St. Edward the Confessor School strives to create a safe and nurturing Catholic environment that recognizes all learners as unique individuals to be treated with dignity and respect. Their curriculum is rooted in academic excellence, respect, confidence, responsibility, faith and cooperation, and encourages cooperation among the school, parents and children as well as the outside community.  Additionally, St. Edward the Confessor School is devoted to helping their students pursue ways of giving back to the community. St. Edward the Confessor School’s proven curriculum and methods of a successful tradition with modern educational advances to provide its students with a rich, qualitative educational experience.

2017: Long Islanders Voted Chaminade High School Best Catholic School on Long Island

Chaminade High School
340 Jackson Ave., Mineola. 516-742-5555. chaminade-hs.org
Long Islanders know that great education can be found in Mineola at the venerable Chaminade High School. Students at Chaminade experience an intense academic, artistic and athletic curricula with a strong emphasis on Catholic values. Those enrolled graduate to attend some of the most prestigious and selective colleges and universities throughout the country! Their philosophy is to combine the ”proven curriculum and methods of a successful tradition with modern pedagogical advances to provide its students with a rich, qualitative educational experience.” Long Islanders believe that these tenets are reflected in the current students, as well as their successful alumni. These are just some of the reasons why Long Islanders voted Chaminade High School the Best Catholic School on Long Island!

2016: Long Islanders Voted St. John the Baptist Best Catholic School on Long Island

St. John the Baptist
1170 Montauk Hwy West Islip. 631-587-8000. stjohnthebaptistdhs.net
Long Islanders know that great education can be found just past the Robert Moses Causeway in West Islip, at the venerable St. John the Baptist Diocesan High School. Students at St. John the Baptist experience an intense academic, artistic and athletic curricula with a strong emphasis on Catholic values. Those enrolled graduate to attend some of the most prestigious and selective colleges and universities throughout the country! Their mission is to “nurture mind, body and soul in an environment of mutual respect, social justice, and loving compassion.” Long Islanders believe that these tenets are reflected in the current students, as well as their successful alumni.

2015: Long Islanders Voted Holy Trinity Diocesan High School Best Catholic School on Long Island!

Holy Trinity Diocesan High School
98 Cherry Ln., Hicksville. 516-433-2900. holytrinityhs.echalk.com

A great education can be found at Holy Trinity. Students at Holy Trinity are treated to an intense academic, artistic and athletic curricula with a strong emphasis on Catholic values. Those enrolled graduate to attend some of the most prestigious and selective colleges and universities throughout the country. Gene Fennell, winner of Best Principal 2013, refers to Holy Trinity Diocesan High School as “a special time, place and spirit.” Long Island voters have made it known that they agree!

2014: Long Islanders Voted Holy Trinity Diocesan High School in Hicksville Best Catholic School on Long Island!

1. Holy Trinity Diocesan High School
98 Cherry Lane, Hicksville. 516-433-2900. holytrinityhs.echalk.com

2. Holy Family School
17 Fordham Ave., Hicksville. 516-938-3846. hfsli.org

3. St. Anthony’s High School
275 Wolf Hill Rd., Melville. 631-271-2020. stanthonyshs.org

2013: Long Islanders Voted Holy Trinity Diocesan High School in Hicksville Best Catholic School on Long Island!

1. Holy Trinity Diocesan High School
98 Cherry Lane, Hicksville. 516-433-2900. www.holytrinityhs.echalk.com

2. St. John The Baptist Diocesan Memorial High School
1170 Montauk Hwy., West Islip. 631-587-8000. www.stjohnthebaptistdhs.net

3. St. Christopher School
15 Pershing Blvd., Baldwin. 516-223-4404. www.stchris-school.org

2012: Long Islanders Voted St. John The Baptist Diocesan Memorial High School Best Catholic School on Long Island!

1. St. John the Baptist Diocesan Memorial High School
1170 Montauk Hwy., West Islip. 631-587-8000. www.stjohnthebaptistdhs.net

2. Holy Trinity High School
98 Cherry Lane, Hicksville. 516-433-2900. holytrinityhs.echalk.com

3. Our Lady of Mercy
520 S. Oyster Bay Rd., Hicksville. 516-433-7040. www.olmshicks.org