Long Island’s nightlife may be overshadowed by a city that never sleeps, but that doesn’t mean Long Islanders don’t know how to have a good time after the sun goes down. Long Island has plenty of nightclubs that are great for dancing, getting drinks and hanging out with a bunch of your closest friends — old and new. If you have a regular place you normally go to, that’s great, but why not try something new this year? Allow us to recommend the Best Nightclub on Long Island.
2025: Long Islanders Voted The Nutty Irishman – Farmingdale Best Nightclub!
The Nutty Irishman – Farmingdale
323 Main Street, Farmingdale
(516) 293-9700 – thenuttyirishman.com
Nutty Irishman’s motto is “Cold Beer, Great Music and Good Times,” but it is far more than that. This place on Main Street in Farmingdale isn’t just a pub offering burgers, wings and NFL games during the day; it’s a place to visit for a sensory club experience at night. Order a perfectly crafted cocktail or one of the 26 different craft beers from national and local breweries lined up on tap, and prepare to dance the night away! An elevated stage, concert-style lighting and a stellar sound system offer music lovers the best atmosphere to enjoy DJs and live bands during a night out with friends. This is a place to visit when you want a nightclub experience, not just a bar.
2024: Long Island Voted Charlotte’s Speakeasy Best Nightclub!
Charlotte’s Speakeasy
294 Main Street, Farmingdale
(516) 586-8530 – charlottesspeakeasy.com
Charlotte’s Speakeasy emerges as the crown jewel of nightlife on Long Island, nestled within the historic confines of Farmingdale Village. Concealed behind a secret bookcase door, beyond the frozen yogurt handles of Charlotte’s Desserts, lies a hidden gem that transports patrons to a bygone era of clandestine revelry. Meticulously restored with a dedication to authenticity, this speakeasy exudes a vibe that’s both nostalgic and electric. Guests are enchanted by the allure of secrecy and sophistication as they sip on expertly crafted cocktails and soak in the ambiance of a bygone era. With the password accessible on their website, Charlotte’s Speakeasy promises an exclusive experience like no other.
2023: Long Islanders Voted Charlotte’s Speakeasy Best Nightclub!
Charlotte’s Speakeasy
294 Main St, Farmingdale
(516) 586-8530 – charlottesspeakeasy.com
If you’re looking to time travel to the Prohibition era, look no further. When the Devito brothers set out on their dream to open an ice cream parlor, they had no idea of the magic in store. Not until the village mayor came for a visit did they realize their desserts were served on top of a gold mine: a historic speakeasy. After doing research and putting their ideas into action, Charlotte’s Speakeasy was born in 2017. Unlike the original old-school speakeasy owners, the Devito brothers are not a crime family but instead, a family that created a space for endless connections. As long as you visit their website to discover the weekly entry password, you’re in for a night of jazz, entertainment, and a historically accurate atmosphere.
2022: Long Islanders Voted Barnum Ballroom Best Nightclub!
Barnum Ballroom
4060 Austin Blvd, Island Park
516-238-7326 – barnumballroom.com
Dubbed the “Great American Showplace,” Island Park’s Barnum Ballroom is known for putting on a good show. Hosting bands, tributes, and DJs, the 5,500 square-foot ballroom provides plenty of room to dance. With two floors in the venue, customers say they enjoy going upstairs to listen to the live music and venturing downstairs to play pool and other games. Performers also love Barnum Ballroom for its lighting, sound, inviting club setting, and circus-like atmosphere. Plus, customers say the food and liquor are reasonably priced. With great music, food, drinks, and games, what more could Long Islanders need for a fun night out?
2021: Long Islanders Voted Mulcahy’s Pub & Concert Hall Best Nightclub!
Mulcahy’s Pub & Concert Hall
3232 Railroad Ave, Wantagh
(631) 783-7500 – muls.com
If you’re looking for a hot spot for you and your friends to enjoy a night on the town, you have to swing by Mulcahy’s Pub & Concert Hall in Wantagh. Mulcahy’s has shows playing all year round, so you are guaranteed to have the night of your life. The club boasts plenty of room to roam plus a food and drink menu to choose from when you come by and stop by the pub. The dress code is smart casual, so you don’t have to dress to the nines just to walk through the door. At Mulcahy’s, the staff will ensure that you have the time of your life.
2020: Long Islanders Voted Lily Flanagan’s Pub Babylon Best Nightclub On Long Island!
Lily Flanagan’s Pub Babylon
345 Deer Park Ave, Babylon
(631) 539-0816 – lilyflanaganspub.com
Founded in 1987, Lily Flanagan’s Pub in Babylon Village has been serving the community for 33 years. Its name comes from the late Lily Flanagan of Limerick, Ireland and the company relocated to its current location in 2007. The menu features typical American fare paired with Irish Pub classics. Menus are upgraded every season and food is created with the freshest and highest, quality ingredients. Diners can enjoy a wide range of meals from a four-course dinner to hearty bar snacks. The lively pub has two oversized 360-degree bars that offer 24 seasonally rotating draft beers, seasonal craft cocktails and classic wines and spirits. Performers from Long Island offer fun live entertainment and there are plenty of themed events like Country Night and karaoke.
2019: Long Islanders Voted Tropix on the Mile Best Nightclub On Long Island!
Tropix on the Mile
395 Woodcleft Ave., Freeport
www.tropixonthemile.com
Tropix on the Mile bills itself as the hottest, nicest and classiest place on the South Shore! Kick your feet up in the sand daytime, kick your feet to music dancing at night. Lively marina haunt with a raw bar & basic American menu, plus a sandy patio, music & a dance floor. South Beach meets Vegas meets Nautical Mile! The menu and service are superb. It’s a venue that can combine being out near the water and at a hot party with the ability to sit down to a nice, delicious meal. Tropix on the Mile will be a part of many of your favorite memories, a place for all occasions.
2018: Long Islanders Voted Treme Blues and Jazz Club Best Nightclub on Long Island
Treme Blues and Jazz Club
553 Main St., Islip, N.Y.
631-277-2008. Tremeislip.com
Named for a neighborhood near New Orleans’ famous French Quarter, Treme Blues and Jazz Club offers the sights and sounds of the Big Easy without leaving Long Island. Treme Blues and Jazz Club regularly features some of the area’s best musicians every night. Along with blues and jazz, the club also hosts artists from other genres including Latin rhythms and dance. While you’re there, be sure to sip on a classic cocktail and nibble on appetizers.
2017: Long Islanders Voted The Emporium Best Nightclub on Long Island
The Emporium
9 Railroad Ave., Patchogue. 631-627-8787. theemporiumny.com
This nightspot features a huge space for live music, dancing, and simply great times overall, with seven bars, two DJ booths, an outdoor beer garden, patio, and even a bowling alley! The staff is always friendly and totally professional. They keep the good times flowing for every patron. Performers love the place because it’s got a great stage and a great sound system. The food is great, too. No wonder The Emporium has been voted the Best Nightclub on Long Island!
2016: Long Islanders Voted Mulcahy’s Pub & Concert Hall Best Nightclub on Long Island
Mulcahy’s Pub & Concert Hall
3232 Railroad Ave., Wantagh. 631-783-7500. muls.com
The night becomes you at Mulcahy’s Pub & Concert Hall in Wantagh, which has won top honors as The Best nightclub on Long Island, and consistently ranks atop this competitive category. Its patrons have spoken. They like it, they really, really like it! The crowd is cool, the vibe is out of this world, the music is guaranteed to blow your mind, and the drinks will flow like liquid joy. When the sun comes down, this place lights up the night. Come dance, and make romance, if that’s your pleasure. Before you know it, you’ll be having a great time in the midnight hour, and beyond!
2015: Long Islanders Voted Lily Flanagan’s Pub Babylon Best Nightclub on Long Island!
Lily Flanagan’s Pub Babylon
345 Deer Park Ave., Babylon. 631-539-0816. lilyflanaganspub.com
The night life hits the high notes at the right nightclub. When the crowd is hot, the music hotter and the vibe is on fire, you want to be where the action is, and Lily Flanagan’s Pub in Babylon is the place to be where the fun never ends once the sun sets. From live music to cool drinks to great food, this venue is on top of its game. Drink, party and dance the night away!
2014: Long Islanders Voted Lily Flanagan’s Pub – Babylon Best Nightclub on Long Island!
1. Lily Flanagan’s Pub – Babylon
345 Deer Park Ave., Babylon. 631-539-0816. lilyflanaganspub.com
2. The Emporium
9 Railroad Ave., Patchogue. 631-627-8787. theemporiumny.com
3. Mulcahy’s Pub & Concert Hall
3232 Railroad Ave., Wantagh. 631-783-7500. muls.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted The Nutty Irishman Best Nightclub on Long Island!
1. The Nutty Irishman
Multiple Locations. www.thenuttyirishman.com
2. The Emporium
9 Railroad Ave., Patchogue. 631-627-8787. www.theemporiumny.com
3. Mulcahy’s Pub & Concert Hall
Multiple Locations. www.muls.com
2012: Long Islanders Voted The Nutty Irishman Best Nightclub on Long Island!
1. The Nutty Irishman
Multiple Locations. www.thenuttyirishman.com
2. Glo Nightclub
737 Merrick Ave., Westbury. 516-794-8022. www.glonightclubli.com
3. Sugar
246 Voice Rd., Carle Place. 516-248-7600. www.sugarli.com
2011: Long Islanders Voted Nutty Irishman in Bay Shore Best Nightclub on Long Island!
1. Nutty Irishman
60 E. Main St., Bay Shore. 631-969-9700. 323 Main St., Farmingdale. 516-293-9700 www.thenuttyirishman.com
2. Mulcahy’s Pub and Concert Hall
3232 Railroad Ave., Wantagh. 516-783-7500. 1702 Middle Country Rd., Centereach. 631-696-1111. www.muls.com
3. The Crazy Donkey
1058 Rte. 110, Farmingdale. 631-753-1975. www.thecrazydonkey.com
2010: Long Islanders Voted The Crazy Donkey in Farmingdale the Best Nightclub on Long Island!
1. The Crazy Donkey
1058 Rte. 110, Farmingdale. 631-753-1975 www.thecrazydonkey.com
2. Mulcahy’s Pub & Concert Hall
3232 Railroad Ave, Wantagh. 516-783-7500. 1702 Middle Country Rd, Centereach. 631-696-1111. www.muls.com
3. The Nutty Irishman
60 E. Main St., Bay Shore. 631-969-9700. 323 Main St., Farmingdale. 516-293-9700. www.thenuttyirishman.com
