People are weird when it comes to spinach. Most dislike it on its own, but when paired with cheese and crust in the form of a pie, they love it. And Long Islanders are no different. Although this food can’t be found at every restaurant on the island, the ones that do serve it do it well. So give the Best Spinach Pie on Long Island a try if you haven’t. If you have, well, then keep on enoying it.
2025: Long Islanders Voted Lindenhurst Diner Best Spinach Pie!
Lindenhurst Diner
195 E Montauk Highway, Lindenhurst
(631) 991-8600 – lindenhurstdiner.com
The Lindenhurst Diner is known for its delicious, homemade spinach pie, a customer favorite that keeps diners coming back. With its warm, welcoming atmosphere and classic diner charm, the Lindenhurst Diner has become a beloved staple for locals and visitors alike. Diners hold a special place in Long Island culture, serving as gathering spots where people come together to enjoy comforting, flavorful meals. In addition to its famous spinach pie, the Lindenhurst Diner offers a wide selection of savory dishes made with quality ingredients and traditional recipes. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick bite or a relaxing meal, the Lindenhurst Diner delivers an authentic Long Island diner experience with a side of hometown pride.
2024: Long Island Voted Lindenhurst Diner Best Spinach Pie!
Lindenhurst Diner
195 E Montauk Highway, Lindenhurst
(631) 991-8600 – lindenhurstdiner.com
At The Lindenhurst Diner, the allure of awesome pie beckons patrons into a realm of culinary excellence. Executed under the culinary mastery of Executive Chef Nicholas Hannides, this cherished diner transcends expectations with a menu marrying classic favorites and contemporary twists, including a dedicated vegan selection. Owner Peter Glykos meticulously curates top-tier ingredients for made-to-order delights, featuring exclusive burger blends and daily-fresh bread. The irresistible lunch deal enhances the Lindenhurst experience, inviting families to savor every moment. Amidst this culinary symphony, don’t miss the homemade spinach pie—a Greek masterpiece crafted by Chef Hannides. Meticulously layered filo dough embraces a divine fusion of fresh spinach and imported feta, baked to perfection daily. Lindenhurst Diner is a haven where culinary dreams come true, and every bite is a celebration of flavor.
2023: Long Islanders Voted Lindenhurst Diner Best Spinach Pie!
Lindenhurst Diner
195 E. Montauk Hwy, Lindenhurst
(631) 991-8601 – lindenhurstdiner.com
Transport yourself to beautiful Greece without even leaving the country when you try The Lindenhurst Diner’s homemade spinach pie. Executive chef Nicholas Hannides concocts a magical marriage of fresh spinach, imported feta, and other secret ingredients into delicate, crispy layers of imported filo dough brushed with melted butter, and bakes it to perfection. Chef Hannides makes each spinach pie by hand and fresh every morning. He has refined his authentic family recipe with owner Peter Glykos to utter impeccability for the ultimate, melt-in-your-mouth spinach pie.
2022: Long Islanders Voted Salvatores of Elmont Pizzeria and Restaurant Best Spinach Pie!
Salvatores of Elmont Pizzeria and Restaurant
312 Meacham Ave, Elmont
(516) 488-8484 – salvatoresofelmont.com
There’s something about a spinach pie that just tastes so good, and Salvatore’s of Elmont Pizzeria & Restaurant has the best tasting spinach pie on Long Island. The filo dough is crispy and cooked perfectly, complimenting the deliciously seasoned stuffing of spinach, onions, and feta cheese. The best way to eat a Salvatore’s spinach pie is to have it right out of the oven, but even if you decide to save it for later you are in for an amazingly savory treat. Don’t forget to grab a tasty side dish from Salvatore’s menu to round out the meal for a delicious lunch option.
2021: Long Islanders Voted The Lindenhurst Diner Best Spinach Pie!
The Lindenhurst Diner
195 E Montauk Hwy, Lindenhurst
(631) 991-8600 – lindenhurstdiner.com
The Lindenhurst Diner has a number of Greek food options on their menu, but nothing quite beats the spinach pie. Also known as spanakopita, the diner’s spinach pie takes freshly cooked spinach, onions and feta baked between flaky layers of filo dough that is savory, crispy and delicious. The Lindenhurst Diner offers the spinach pie as an appetizer or as a meal alongside a Greek salad, so you have options depending on how hungry you are. Your mouth will be watering by the time the spinach pie makes it to your table, and once you take a bite you will feel as though you have been transported right to Athens.
2020: Long Islanders Voted The Food Mill Best Spinach Pie!
The Food Mill
40 Lido Blvd, Point Lookout
(516) 992-8888 – foodmillny.com
The Food Mill has been providing healthy alternatives to the people of Long Island since 1930. They strive to offer top-notch pre-made meals that are healthy for you and the freshest ingredients you can find. While the people of Long Island definitely love the store, it is their spinach pie that takes them over the top! Rich with flavor and crafted with excellence, this pie is irresistible to anyone who loves this vegetable. The Food Mill hopes to inspire healthy living among those they come into contact with, and the people of Long Island are thankful!
2019: Long Islanders Voted Vito’s Ristorante & Pizza Best Spinach Pie!
Vito’s Ristorante & Pizza
91 Forest Ave., Glen Cove
(516) 759-1366 – www.vitospizzany.com
Nobody on Long Island makes a better spinach pie than Vito’s Ristorante. The quintessential pizzeria serves up a spinach pie chock full of the leafy green with cheese and garlic. It’s the perfect complement to the traditional regular pie that you’ll find at this Brooklyn-born pizzeria serving up the best Italian food on the island for decades.
2018: Long Islanders Voted Athenian Greek Taverna Best Spinach Pie on Long Island!
Athenian Greek Taverna
2187 Jericho Turnpike
Commack, NY 11725
631-499-7660 / atheniangreektaverna.com
To the warm and welcoming staff of Athenian Greek Taverna, it’s spanakopita. But you can call it spinach pie. No matter what you call it, nobody does it better than Athenian. Layers of flaky phyllo dough and spinach greens with a feta cheese mixture–a perfect balance of delicious flavors. Like everything cooked up at Athenian, the spinach pie is made “Yiayia’s way,” just like grandma makes it, with fresh and authentic ingredients. Make Yiayia proud and be sure to order enough spinach pie to share with everyone on your next visit to Athenian Greek Taverna.
2017: Long Islanders Voted The Greek Place Best Spinach Pie on Long Island
The Greek Place 2144 Jericho Tpke., Garden City Park. 516-673-4545. thegreekplacegcp.com For the third year in a row, The Greek Place’s spinach pie has won the hearts of Long Islanders, and for good reason! A crispy outer-layer with just the right amount of crunch, a delicious filling, and a whole lotta love, The Greek Place provides their customers with the very Best Spinach Pie on Long Island thanks to Chef Pete’s talent, creativity, and passion. After just one bite, you’ll be hooked! Opa!
2016: Long Islanders Voted The Greek Place Best Spinach Pie on Long Island
The Greek Place 2144 Jericho Tpke., Garden City. 516-673-4545. thegreekplacegcp.com We said it last year and we’ll repeat it again: Spanakopita, prepared the right way, possesses transcendental powers. From its crispy-yet-tender outer layer to its moist, filling interior, The Greek Place’s spinach pie can remedy your appetite and soothe your very soul. This special treat is the culmination of more than two decades of culinary fortitude, and is the perfect accompaniment to any number of Chef Pete’s legendary Greek creations!
2015: Long Islanders Voted The Greek Place Best Spinach Pie on Long Island!
The Greek Place 2144 Jericho Tpke., Garden City Park. 516-673-4545. thegreekplacegcp.com A good spinach pie—with its crusty exterior and oh-so joyously soft, green, leafy insides—can go a long way to satisfy your soul. There, we’ve said it. Spanakopita, prepared the right way, possesses transcendental powers. Legions of Long Islanders agree, as The Greek Place’s crowning at the top of this competitive category is testament. Try one of these magical treats for lunch and experience what so many already know, then pick up a few for your friends and family. They’ll thank you, that’s for sure!
2014: Long Islanders Voted Greek Town in Rockville Centre Best Spinach Pie on Long Island!
1. Greek Town 90 N. Village Ave., Rockville Centre. 516-678-4549. greektownrvc.net 2. The Greek Place 2144 Jericho Tpke., Garden City Park. 516-673-4545. thegreekplacegcp.com 3. Opa Grill Multiple Locations. theopagrille.com
